The National Association of Immigration Judges (NAIJ) has asked the United States Supreme Court to allow them to challenge a Department of Justice policy in federal district courts. The policy limits their ability to publicly share their views about immigration and the agency they work for.


The request was made on November 17, 2026. The association says the policy introduced by the Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) violates judges’ First Amendment rights, which protect freedom of speech under the US Constitution.


The policy requires judges to get approval from their superiors before making public statements about their work. It also limits their ability to speak in their personal capacity about immigration issues or the agency they work for.


According to Newsweek and Columbia University's Knight First Amendment Institute, the judges say the policy prevents them from sharing their views with the public on issues related to justice and the work of immigration authorities.


They also say that when they try to challenge the policy, they are told to first go through a government process for handling employee complaints instead of taking the matter directly to a federal court. They argue that this could delay the protection of their rights.


In their request, the judges used the phrase “First Amendment black hole” to explain their concern that the policy could leave them without a clear way to protect their freedom of speech through the courts.


The case has been going through the courts for several years, but no final decision has been made on whether the policy violates the US Constitution.

The judges are asking the Supreme Court to allow them to take their complaint to a federal district court without having to wait until they face punishment before challenging the policy.


The case has renewed debate over the right of government employees to speak about public issues and the limits authorities can place on what they say.